Witcher who is guilty

A bit old of a topic, but I usually choose Abigail. While she may have sold those poisons That's like blaming the blacksmith of murder for supplying the sword that killed a person. In the end, its the way the person who had it used it that is at fault At least, that's how I see it. Haren shows more then enough pride in supplying the Squirrels, and even deals with a child abduction ring of Salamandras I'm sure he got into that mess himself, for money.

And Odo, I agree, killed his brother and probably his father? Poor Odo's Dog, still guarding his true master's grave. I never once feel guilty, no matter how many times I've replayed this game, for choosing Abigail over the villagers.

And even then, Gerrault was willing to let them go so long as they did not harm Abigail. It was the Reverend, Odo, Haren, and some thugs that attacked afterward. I wish there were more games like it. Originally posted by soldier :. I don't think Abigail ever had a clean shoulder, right from the moment she stepped foot in the village. I must find a way to lure Azar into a trap. I promised Raymond to eliminate the boss of the Salamander's armed forces - Ramsmeat.

I have to prepare well, as he seems to be a tough opponent. I have to kill Ramsmeat. I told Raymond that I had killed Ramsmeat. He is going to wait for me near the tower. I must lure Kalkstein to the tower in the swamp.

Raymond gave me a Sephirah which forms a part of the key to the tower. All that remains is to take what's inside the tower and we'll get that bastard Kalkstein once and for all. I have to open the tower. I have found the magic treatise that Kalkstein desired so badly.

For years, it lay safely hidden away in the tower in the swamp. Azar is in for an unpleasant surprise. I must prepare to face Azar Javed. Azar, who impersonated Raymond, is behind all this. I must lure him into a trap. I will tell "Raymond" that I killed Ramsmeat. I must prepare to face Azar. Everything is going smoothly. The fake private investigator gave me his Sephirah.

Now I can stop pretending. I must get inside the tower to defeat the false Raymond. I have found the magic treatise that Azar desired so badly. Witcher Wiki Explore. Witcher Series. Explore Wikis Community Central. Register Don't have an account? Vizima Confidential. Edit source History Talk 1. Do you like this video? Play Sound. Wrong conclusion Autopsy Results [ ] Autopsy implicated Kalkstein : I told Raymond about what we found during the autopsy.

Autopsy implicated Ramsmeat : I told Raymond about what we found during the autopsy. The evidence points to Ramsmeat. Subterfuge [ ] I told "Raymond" that I discovered nothing during the autopsy. Ramsmeat is Dead [ ] I killed Ramsmeat. Time to report to Raymond. Opening the Tower [ ] Raymond gave me a Sephirah which forms a part of the key to the tower.

Don't have an account? Sign up for free! What do you need help on? Cancel X. Topic Archived Page 1 of 2 Last. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. Boards The Witcher so who was really guilty in chapter one?

User Info: DestructiveCow. User Info: jedifish. Everyone is partly responsible for the tragedies that occurred in the village, but as the game suggested, you simply choose the path of the lesser evil or not. User Info: SlaynCruz.

Yep, everyone's in the wrong at least somewhat. It's one of the themes of the game: "There is no good, no evil - only decisions and consequences. User Info: miltos User Info: ReturnofYesMan. It is part of Geralt 's investigation into Salamandra.

As the No. With almost every clue about the alchemist obscured by currently unreachable ends, like the mysterious witcher Berengar himself, there is really not much can be done by Geralt. Unlike other suspect quests, this quest can only progress passively through the influence of other quests and events, often making it the last suspect quest to be completed. Regardless of the fashion in which the quest progressed, however, at this point the suspect is only deemed innocent or guilty.

With this many ways to progress the quest, naturally there are multiple endings as well, with differences in XP and potential impact on other related quests. However, due to the nature of suspect quests, it is likely that similarly worded dialogue options leading to different endings are present at the same time, causing great confusion.